With Voting on the Rise, Poor Voters Could Be Pivotal in November

Former vice president Joe Biden courting Black voters at the Bethel AME Church in Wilmington, Del., earlier this year. Photo by Jim Watson/AFP via Getty Images

Low-income voters are less likely to participate in national elections than voters with higher incomes – but a new report says voting rates are on the rise, and low-income voters could sway elections in 2020.

There were some 350,000 low-income persons eligible to vote who did not vote in Maryland for the 2016 presidential election, according to the study released Tuesday by Columbia School of Social Work Assistant Professor Robert Paul Hartley. At the time, Maryland had a total of 4.1 million persons eligible to vote – meaning low-income non-voters comprised more than 8% of the total electorate.

“The low-income electorate is a substantial group that votes less often than higher-income individuals although at similar trends and changes in voting patterns over time,” Hartley wrote in the report. “This is a group that could mobilize if they were more engaged by candidates or campaigns, or if they believed that voting might make a difference.”

The report was released by the Poor People’s Campaign: A National Call for Moral Revival, a national coalition to address poverty and systemic racism. During a Tuesday press call, leaders from the coalition said voters with low incomes could have a significant impact on elections across the country this year. 

The Rev. William J. Barber II, a co-chair of the Poor People’s Campaign, said he hopes the report will spur politicians to reach out to low-income voters.

“It is political suicide, it is political foolishness, not to reach out to poor and low-income people,” Barber said.

Rev. William J. Barber II, co-chair of the Poor People’s Campaign. Photo courtesy of Repairers of the Breach.

Barber emphasized that poverty isn’t a marginal issue: 62 million Americans don’t make a living wage, and some 140 million were low-income even before the coronavirus pandemic. He said COVID-19 has led to “economic annihilation” among the working poor.

While low-income non-voters wouldn’t have swayed the outcome of the 2016 election in Maryland, they could have in other states. Hartley wrote that if 1% more low-income voters, who were eligible to vote, had gone to the polls, they could have turned the election in Michigan. And likewise, a 4% to 7% increase would have equaled margins of victory in several battleground states, including Florida, New Hampshire, Pennsylvania, or Wisconsin.

The study defined low-income people as anyone whose income was lower than two times the level set as the official poverty line.

“Poor and low-income people can become a transformative new electorate,” the Rev. Liz Theoharis, also a co-chair of the Poor People’s Campaign, said.

Voting rates are rising among both high- and low- income voters. Hartley wrote that a gap still exists between voters based on income, but added that there was a roughly 10% increase in voting rates for the last midterm election.

Hartley also noted an increase in vote-by-mail across the United States between both high and low income voters, writing that they “have similar trends of increasingly voting by mail, yet the low-income population is less likely to vote overall.”

Low-income voters face more barriers than those with higher incomes when they head to the polls, Hartley wrote. Voters with lower incomes are less likely to vote because of “illness, disability, or transportation issues,” according to the study.

People of color make up a disproportionate number of low-income voters, Barber noted. Black and Latino voters have long been subject to voter suppression and disenfranchisement in the United States, and advocates have warned that the coronavirus pandemic could lead to disenfranchisement on the Nov. 3 election day.

While low-income, eligible non-voters make up roughly 8% of Maryland’s electorate, other states have a much larger proportion. For midterm elections in Arkansas, Kentucky, Mississippi, New Mexico, Oklahoma, Tennessee, and West Virginia and other states, low-income non-voters make up nearly a fifth of the total electorate.