Skip to main content
Government & Politics

Sen. Astle Loses Mayoral Primary; Gutierrez Moves On, Hettleman Stays Put

Veteran state Sen. John Astle (D) has lost his bid to become mayor of Annapolis, dropping the Democratic primary Tuesday to restaurateur Gavin Buckley.

Buckley, who owns several establishments on West Street, claimed victory at his Metropolitan restaurant after Astle conceded at Harry Browne’s. He’ll face first-term Republican Mayor Mike Panelides, who easily won his primary Tuesday, in November.


Gavin Buckley

Buckley took 2,362 votes to Astle’s 1,455.

In an interview Tuesday night with The Capital, Buckley called his victory “a rush.”

“How do you beat a guy with the whole machine behind him?” he said.

The Democratic establishment, which almost uniformly got behind Astle in the primary, is now poised to support Buckley in the general election. Pantelides is a rising Republican star, and Democrats would dearly like to knock him off.

Astle, who ran unsuccessfully for mayor in 1981, was elected to the House of Delegates a year later and won his Senate seat in 1994. He had billed his mayoral bid as a last political hurrah – but Democratic voters had other ideas.

Astle’s plans for 2018 are now unclear. Democratic activist Sarah Elfreth has been actively campaigning for his Senate seat – a top target for Republicans. Former Del. Ron George is seeking the GOP nomination, and Del. Herb McMillan (R) has not ruled out a bid.

Astle told The Capital Tuesday night he would “take a look” at another Senate run.

Gutierrez to Council Race. The upheaval in legislative District 18 continues. Already state Sen. Rich Madaleno (D) is running for governor, and Del. Jeff Waldstreicher (D) is running to replace him.

Now Del. Ana Sol Gutierrez (D), the first Latina elected to the General Assembly, back in 2002, is running for a seat on the Montgomery County Council.

Gutierrez, whose political career in Montgomery County dates back to 1990, filed to participate in the county’s public finance system this week. On Tuesday she confirmed to Maryland Reporter that she is joining the crowded Democratic primary in the 1st council District.


Del. Ana Sol Gutierrez

Gutierrez called the Dist. 1 vacancy – term-limited Councilmember Roger Berliner (D) is running for county executive – “really an incredible opportunity to continue to serve the residents of Montgomery County.”

“The importance of being politically active and involved today – under the current administration and what I see as threats to our democratic principles – means now is not the time to retire and sit by the wayside,” the 75-year-old lawmaker added.

In an email to Maryland Matters Tuesday evening, Gutierrez said she would release a statement later in the week further explaining her decision.

Gutierrez joins a Democratic primary for Council that includes videographer Bill Cook; former Kensington mayor Peter Fosselman; Andrew Friedson, a former top aide to Comptroller Peter Franchot (and a member of the Maryland Matters steering committee);  Reggie Oldak, a tax attorney, advocate for women’s issues and former chief of staff to Berliner; and Meredith Wellington, a labor attorney and former member of the Montgomery County Planning Board.

Back in Dist. 18, it appears that only incumbent Del. Al Carr (D) will seek re-election. Also seeking House seats are Democrats Mila Johns, a terrorism researcher and analyst; Emily Shetty, a policy consultant and former congressional staffer who ran unsuccessfully in 2014; and Jared Solomon, a former teacher and Capitol Hill staffer who formally announced his bid on Tuesday.

Other Democrats could join the House race. Dana Beyer, a civil rights activist who challenged Madaleno in the 2014 Democratic Senate primary, has not ruled out running for a legislative seat.

Hettleman Won’t Take on Zirkin. After pondering a challenge to state Sen. Bobby Zirkin (D) for months, Del. Shelly Hettleman (D) announced Tuesday that she’ll seek a second term representing Baltimore County’s 11th District.

“I love serving in the House of Delegates,” Hettleman wrote on her Facebook page. “I am very proud to have been successful in sponsoring and, with the support of my colleagues, enacting legislation to expand the accessibility of contraception, protect vulnerable older adults, expand access to healthy food, create a statewide standard for how rape kits are handled by law enforcement, address sexual assault on campus, and a number of other bills that have become law.”


Del. Shelly Hettleman

Many progressives had hoped Hettleman would try to take out Zirkin, the chairman of the Senate Judicial Proceedings Committee. He has infuriated liberals by opposing paid sick leave legislation that passed the legislature this year but was vetoed by Gov. Larry Hogan (R) and by speaking at fundraisers for Republicans who serve on his committee. Hettleman said in her statement that ensuring the legislature overrides Hogan’s veto is one of her priorities for the 2018 session.

But a clue that Hettleman wasn’t going to take on Zirkin was visible in the latest edition of the Baltimore Jewish Times – an ad featuring all four members of the Dist. 11 legislative delegation, wishing readers a Happy New Year. You can see the ad here, on p. 63.


Our stories may be republished online or in print under Creative Commons license CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. We ask that you edit only for style or to shorten, provide proper attribution and link to our website. Please see our republishing guidelines for use of photos and graphics.

If you have any questions, please email [email protected].

To republish, copy the following text and paste it into your HTML editor.


Creative Commons License AttributionCreative Commons Attribution
Sen. Astle Loses Mayoral Primary; Gutierrez Moves On, Hettleman Stays Put